Good or Bad?

The second discourse of Fihi Ma-Fih, starts with someone saying "Mawlana does not utter a word". Mawlana replies; it was the thought of me, which brings him to my presence. My imagine without words draws him here.

Words are the shadow reality, one piece of it in several pieces. If shadow could draw, reality would draw all the more. Words are just pretexts. It is the inner bond that binds one people to another, not words. Although someone witnesses to several miracles, hears hundreds of words, if he/she does not have the inner bond with that prophet or saint, it is useless.

It is the imagines draws everything. Imagine of a garden, brings us a garden. Imagine of a shop brings us a shop. (Does it remind you the very popular book "Secret" but this is another hot topic to be treated) However, there is a deception hidden in these images. Sometimes, you go somewhere with the expectation of good, however you just find disappointment there. These images are just shrouds covering something.

I remembered a story upon this discourse of Mawlana.

Once upon a time, there was a Sultan and his best friend. One day, they go hunting in the forest. However, when the Sultan shots, something happens to his rifle and his thumb falls apart with the bullet he fired. He wails within pain. He rebels against God. His best friend says, "Don't worry your majesty. Maybe that is good for you. Nobody but only God could know what is good for us." Sultan gets very angry to his best friend and sentences him to jail and his friend says "Maybe that is good for me, as God wanted this happen".

A few years pass and Sultan leaves for an overseas vacation. Unfortunately his ship sinks and he reaches to an island. However, there a cannibal tribe lives on the island and they capture the Sultan. While they are preparing the fire to cook him, they realize that the Sultan has a missing thumb and they give up eating him since their believe does not allow them to eat people with missing organs. Feeling a great happiness, Sultan leaves the island and return his country and starts with releasing his best friend from jail. Sultan says; "You were right, I missed my thumb that was good for me because cannibals released me, however you were also wrong because I imprisoned you that was bad for you. You spend several years in jail." His friend says: "No my friend that was good for me either. If you did not put me in jail, I would be accompanying you in your trip and since I have all my organs in full, they would be eaten me".


I think just like that, we are not in capable of foreseeing everything and know what is good or what is bad for us. So sometimes (maybe always) it is best to grasp the things coming from God...

Intention of Being

First story of Fihi Ma-Fih starts with a proverb regarding scholars. Mawlana says; The worst of scholars are those who visit princes. Such a great prince stands at the door of the poor; such a wretch poor stands at door of the prince.

Mawlana says; most of the people do not understand the inner meaning of this proverb and explains: The worst scholars are those who behave upon princes. They revolve their life in order to get princes' attention and praise.

In a very pragmatic way of thinking it could be said that, even though the purpose is attaining the princes praise, the person becomes a scholar and there is nothing wrong with it. However, purpose of an action is attached importance in Islam. It is believed that, if intention of an act is pure good, the people will deemed in good deeds even the results occurred badly.

I just recall a memory of mine. Once I met with an Imam when I was in law school. I asked him, "if I decide to be a judge, what shall I do while rendering a decision, what if I decide wrong?". He said that, "If you believe in what you decide and your decision is right, lets say you will have 100 good deeds. Deciding wholeheartedly and according to law of course, if you give wrong decision you will have 10 good deeds instead of 100. The matter is, if you believe, your decision is right or not." This story impressed me so much. However I have not become a judge. Story of another day...

Fihi Ma-Fih

Fihi Ma-Fih is book piled from the conversation of Mawlana. Some of his followers recorded his conversations, the questions answered by him and while he was annotating Prophet's words or Quran. It is not possible to give details about the dates, places and participants however believed that it was started to record these conversations while Mawlana was alive but they were not composed as book.

Arguments are handled very clearly and very clear and simple examples were given. However, many stories of Fihi Ma-Fih has maybe not esoteric but deeper meanings which is hard to understand. Especially Mawlana used lots of references to Quran, Prophet's words and other Islamic doctrine. In this blog, I will try to explain the references as far as I could while translating the stories into a plain language.

Starting

Like giving birth to a baby, starting is the hardest part of this task.

It was a while ago when the idea of publishing Mawlana's short stories flashed in my brain. Considering my poor English skills I gave up several times. Then I remember an old story about an ant who wants to go and visit Mecca. Every animal in the jungle tease with the ant since the ant is so small to take a long journey there. Then they ask to the ant, "How could you possibly arrive there" and ant answers "No matter I arrive there or not. It worth dieing while trying to arrive."

So the story triggered me again and here I am. I hope the spirit of Mawlana enlightens my way. I am just a humble servant who is trying to reach up his way.